🚀 Launch offer: Sign up free and get 60 days full Pro access — no credit card needed. Claim it →

← Back to blog
Compliance2 Jul 2026 · 10 min read

ICO Enforcement in 2025–26: Key Lessons for UK SMEs

The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) has fined organisations of every size in the last two years, from a £60,000 fine on a small law firm to £14 million on Capita. The failings behind them are consistent: weak security (above all, no multi-factor authentication), marketing without consent, and not protecting children's data. Here's what UK businesses can learn.

£20m
Largest ICO fine (British Airways, 2020)
£14.47m
Reddit, children's data (Feb 2026)
£14m
Capita, cyber attack (Oct 2025)
979 / 1,000
Top UK websites passing the ICO's cookie test (Dec 2025)

Size is not a defence. Small firms have been fined too, such as a law firm fined £60,000 in 2025. If you collect personal data, UK GDPR applies to you whatever your size.

1Notable ICO enforcement actions 2024–26

These cases illustrate the patterns in ICO enforcement and the specific failures that trigger action:

DPP Law Ltd (April 2025)£60,000

A small law firm. Attackers got in through a rarely used administrator account that had no multi-factor authentication and took 32GB of data. The firm reported the breach 43 days late, because it didn't realise that losing access to personal data is a breach too.

Advanced Computer Software (March 2025)£3.07 million

Ransomware disrupted NHS 111 and other services. Attackers used a customer account without multi-factor authentication. It was the ICO's first fine on a data processor (a supplier), not the organisation that owns the data.

23andMe (June 2025)£2.31 million

A credential stuffing attack exposed the data of 155,592 UK users. No mandatory multi-factor authentication, weak password rules, and a slow response.

Capita (October 2025)£14 million

A 2023 cyber attack exposed data of 6.6 million people. Weak access controls and a 58-hour delay responding to a high-priority security alert.

Reddit (February 2026)£14.47 million

No effective age checks, so children under 13 used the service and their data was processed without a lawful basis.

KRA Consultancy (May 2026)£300,000

Sent over 5.5 million unsolicited marketing texts, including fake bailiff messages, leading to more than 60,000 complaints.

The DPP Law case is particularly instructive for small businesses: the fine was not for being attacked, but for missing a basic control (multi-factor authentication) and reporting late. The ICO's test is whether you took appropriate steps for the risk, not whether a breach happened.

2What the ICO is actively targeting

Based on ICO enforcement notices, reprimands, and public guidance issued in 2024–25, these are the areas under active scrutiny:

  • →Cookie consent: advertising cookies set before a choice, or rejecting made harder than accepting. The ICO tested the UK's top 1,000 websites and by December 2025 979 passed, many after ICO letters or preliminary enforcement notices.
  • →Marketing emails without valid consent: purchasing lists, using "soft opt-in" without understanding the rules, sending to contacts who haven't consented to email marketing.
  • →Inadequate security: no MFA on admin accounts, unpatched software, no data encryption at rest, no security incident response plan.
  • →Failure to respond to DSARs (Subject Access Requests): missing the one-month deadline, providing incomplete responses, or charging fees where none are permitted.
  • →Unlawful retention: keeping customer data indefinitely with no deletion schedule or documented retention policy.
  • →Privacy notices: missing or inadequate notices that don't reflect actual data processing, or using generic templates without customisation.

3The EU picture

EU fines don't apply in the UK, but they show which failings regulators treat most seriously. The largest EU GDPR fines have been for unlawful international transfers and for advertising without a valid legal basis.

The largest single GDPR fine is €1.2 billion against Meta Platforms Ireland (May 2023) for US data transfers. Others include Amazon €746 million (2021, advertising), TikTok €530 million (2025, transfers to China), Instagram €405 million (2022, children's data), LinkedIn €310 million (2024, behavioural advertising) and Uber €290 million (2024, transfers).

4The ICO's approach to SMEs

The ICO has published guidance on its approach to smaller organisations. In practice, the Commissioner uses a range of tools beyond fines — reprimands, enforcement notices, and published case summaries — that damage reputation even without a financial penalty.

The ICO typically investigates following a complaint from a data subject, a mandatory breach notification, or proactive sweeps (such as cookie compliance audits across specific sectors). You do not need to be the subject of a large breach for an investigation to begin — a single complaint about an unlawful marketing email is sufficient to trigger a case.

The ICO publishes all enforcement actions on its website, including the name of the organisation and the specific breach. Reputational damage from being named in an ICO enforcement notice often exceeds the financial cost for smaller businesses. Customers, partners, and investors check the register.

4The five most common SME compliance failures

  • →1. Cookie banners that don't actually block cookies before consent — analytics scripts load before the user clicks anything. Technically illegal, common, and increasingly enforced.
  • →2. Privacy policies copied from templates that don't reflect actual data processing. Your policy must accurately describe your specific tools, purposes, and lawful bases.
  • →3. No Data Processing Agreements with processors — if you use Mailchimp, HubSpot, Xero, or any SaaS tool, you need a DPA. Most providers offer one but you must accept it.
  • →4. Subject access requests ignored or answered late. Anyone can ask for the data you hold about them, and you must respond within one calendar month.
  • →5. No documented retention and deletion schedule. "We keep it forever" is not a lawful retention period. You need a documented schedule and you need to follow it.

6How to reduce your ICO risk

  • →Scan your website: use a real scanning tool that checks what scripts load before cookie consent is given. Browser developer tools alone won't catch everything.
  • →Review your cookie banner: ensure the reject option is as prominent as accept, and nothing loads before consent is given.
  • →Check your privacy policy covers your actual tools and processing — not just generic categories.
  • →Audit your processor list: every SaaS tool that touches personal data needs a DPA. Go through your subscriptions and check.
  • →Set up a DSAR process: know where data is held, designate someone to handle requests, and track each deadline (one calendar month from receipt).
  • →Implement basic security hygiene: MFA on all admin accounts, password manager, encrypted backups, basic incident response plan.
  • →Document everything: the ICO responds well to evidence of good faith efforts to comply. A documented compliance programme, even if imperfect, demonstrates accountability.

AlgoGrass performs a live scan of your website to identify the compliance gaps most likely to attract ICO attention — cookie consent failures, missing privacy notices, data form issues, and HTTPS problems. Run a free scan →

7If you receive an ICO complaint or investigation

If the ICO contacts you, respond promptly and cooperatively. The ICO's enforcement guidance emphasises that voluntary cooperation and swift remediation are mitigating factors in penalty decisions. A fine that might be £200,000 in an egregious case may be reduced significantly where the organisation demonstrates genuine efforts to comply and remediate.

  • →Don't ignore communications — the ICO treats non-cooperation seriously
  • →Gather your documentation: processing records, consent evidence, security policies, DSAR response records
  • →Consider seeking legal advice from a data protection solicitor
  • →Remediate the issue quickly and document what you've done
  • →Be honest: if something went wrong, acknowledge it and explain what you've changed

Find your compliance gaps before the ICO does

AlgoGrass scans your live website for the exact issues the ICO investigates — cookie consent failures, missing privacy notices, insecure forms, and missing documents. Fix them before they become enforcement actions.

Scan my website free →